Google Health .VS. MedMemory Online PHR Safety ComparisonMedMemory’s has chosen not to offer a online service like that offered by Google Health for many of the reasons outlined below. With a MedMemory Personal Health Record (PHR) you are in total control of all your medical records! Visit our Health Information Manager page http://medmemory.com/health-information-manager.html to find out more about how MedMemory can help you store, organize, and record your Personal Health Record.
Electronic health records raise doubt
Google service's inaccuracies may hold wide lessonBy Lisa Wangsness Globe Staff / April 13, 2009
WASHINGTON - When Dave deBronkart, a tech-savvy kidney cancer survivor, tried to transfer his medical records from Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center to Google Health, a new free service that lets patients keep all their health records in one place and easily share them with new doctors, he was stunned at what he found. Google said his cancer had spread to either his brain or spine - a frightening diagnosis deBronkart had never gotten from his doctors - and listed an array of other conditions that he never had, as far as he knew, like chronic lung disease and aortic aneurysm. A warning announced his blood pressure medication required "immediate attention." "I wondered, 'What are they talking about?' " said deBronkart, who is 59 and lives in Nashua. DeBronkart eventually discovered the problem: Some of the information in his Google Health record was drawn from billing records, which sometimes reflect imprecise information plugged into codes required by insurers. Google Health and others in the fast-growing personal health record business say they are offering a revolutionary tool to help patients navigate a fragmented healthcare system, but some doctors fear that inaccurate information from billing data could lead to improper treatment. "The problem is this kind of information should never be used clinically, especially if you don't have starting or ending dates" attached to each problem, said deBronkart's primary care doctor, Daniel Z. Sands, who is also the director of medical informatics at Cisco Systems. Personal health records, such as those offered by Google Health, are a promising tool for patients' empowerment - but inaccuracies could be "a huge problem," said Dr. Paul Tang, the chief medical information officer for the Palo Alto Medical Foundation, who chairs a health technology panel for the National Quality Forum. For example, he said, an inaccurate diagnosis of gastrointestinal bleeding on a heart attack patient's personal health record could stop an emergency room doctor from administering a life-saving drug. Ideally insurance claims could provide a trove of data that could greatly accelerate the Obama administration's effort to computerize all medical records within five years. The stimulus package contained $17 billion to help computerize doctors' records. But transferring existing information from paper or outdated computers could take years and hundreds of millions of dollars to complete. Insurance data, by contrast, is already computerized and far easier and cheaper to download. But it is also prone to inaccuracies, partly because of the clunky diagnostic coding language used for medical billing, or because doctors sometimes label a test with the disease they hope to rule out, medical technology specialists say. "Claims data is notoriously inaccurate and notoriously incomplete with respect to an expression of the problems a person has," said Dr. David Kibbe, a senior technology adviser to the American Academy of Family Physicians. Google Health directed questions to Dr. Roni Zeiger, a product manager for the company; he said Google draws its information from a variety of sources sent by its partner hospitals, pharmacies, and laboratories, including claims data. He acknowledged that such billing information can sometimes be imprecise, but he argued that the overall benefit of having some information is better than no information and that accuracy will improve over time. For example, he said, a list of allergies, medications and recent lab reports can save a patient's life, particularly in an emergency. "Test results from last week can make the difference between the right decision and the wrong decision," he said. Zeiger said doctors need to evaluate information based on where it comes from and calibrate treatment decisions accordingly, which they often have to do anyway with paper records that can be incomplete, disorganized, or unavailable. But Google records do not always clearly indicate the source of data for each diagnosis. "That's something I think we could do better on," Zeiger said. DeBronkart's case shows how accuracy gets lost in translation. His cancer had at one point spread to his skull, but there is no code for that, so the hospital probably instead used the code for metastases to the brain or spine, according to Sands. "Chronic lung disease" probably refers to the bronchitis deBronkart has had at various points in recent years. "Anxiety disorder" apparently referred to the anxiety deBronkart complained about during intensive chemotherapy, at a time he thought he might have months to live - though he has not experienced it before or since. The list of diagnoses also gave no indication of their severity. "Aortic aneurysm" was probably a slight widening of his aorta, Sands said, not a blood-filled bulge that burst. Google also did not date-stamp many of deBronkart's problems, so at times it did not distinguish current issues (cancer) from past ones (low potassium levels two years ago). Some of the dates were wrong - his cancer diagnosis was months off. Patients who discover mistakes in their health records can delete information, add notes, or ask providers to correct problems. Dr. Todd Taylor, a former emergency room doctor who now works for Microsoft Health Solutions group, which makes the personal health record Microsoft HealthVault, said patients "need to take an active role in managing their health data," preferably by reviewing them with a medical professional. DeBronkart, an early Internet enthusiast, considers himself an "e-patient," someone who regularly connects with other patients and doctors to learn about his own healthcare. He and Sands speak at conferences on the importance of active patient involvement. But it was not immediately clear to deBronkart how to fix the errors in his Google Health record. At first he wanted the hospital to handle it, but that would involve changing codes on insurance bills from years ago, said Dr. John Halamka, chief information officer at Beth Israel Deaconess. Ironically, Beth Israel has one of the most advanced electronic medical records systems in the country, with clinical records carefully tended by doctors and accessible to patients on a secure website. Sands, his doctor, said if deBronkart needed quick access to his file, he would be better off using the Beth Israel system. But Google Health prefers providers send information in coded form to build the list of a patient's medical conditions so the program can guide patients to additional information on the Internet about each disease using links. The neatly packaged billing codes are easier to link to than the mix of medical terms and standard language doctors use in their clinical records. Halamka and Zeiger said the records will improve as more precise coding language is adopted in the coming years. Halamka said thousands of Beth Israel patients have had access to Google Health since last May, but deBronkart is the only one who has complained of serious problems. In the meantime, said Tang, who was recently appointed to a new committee advising the Obama administration on health technology, the risks to patients need to be studied further. "Probably for some patients it's a net benefit, and for others it's a risk," he said. "We need to know what the risks are so we can mitigate them better." DeBronkart - who blogged about his Google Health experience on the website e-patients.net - has some simple advice for patients who use personal health records. "Check it," he said. "See if it's accurate." The Health Information Manager: The Next Generation Of Medical ID's & Identification Is Here!The modern history of Medical Identification started with Military Dog Tags and has progressed to medical bracelets and now the next generation medical identification and medical records management is a MedMemory Personal Health Record The MedMemory Health Information Manager is a Personal Health Record that is a revolutionary advancement of traditional medical identification products that allows an individual to store critical health and medical records with other key information on a Medical Alert designed flash drive. The MedMemory PHR is the future of medical identification - a great management tool for Caregivers, Business Travelers and must have for PERS users. Included with every MedMemory Medical-Alert PHR purchase are 15 Health, Medical and Lifestyle Forms. Some of the included templates are: Medical Release Form, Power of Attorney, Living Will, Emergency Contacts Form, Advance Directives Form, Allergy Log, Immunization Log, Diabetes Log, Insurance Forms and Providers Template. To view all templates click here: http://medmemory.com/templates.html About The MedMemory Health Information Manager As an electronic Medical Identification PHR Medical-Alert / Medical Bracelet type device, MedMemory can store a dazzling array of critical information, such as lab results including glucose measurements, cholesterol readings, blood pressure readings and your current weight. This product doubles as a Medical-Alert / Medical Identification / PERS - personal emergency response system - and can store identifying information that can make a huge difference in the event of an emergency. As an electronic health record (EHR), MedMemory can hold imaging results like X-rays, CT scans, MRs, PETs and ultrasounds; additional tests and readings - like EKGs and pulmonary functioning tests - can be stored on MedMemory as well.
MedMemory is a personal high tech Medical-Alert / Medical Identification program and storage device that you can bring it with you everywhere, including to doctor's visits. Rather than experiencing the delays associated with transferring records from office to office you can have them on hand and bring them along anywhere they go; it is a genuine health record. Redundant tests are eliminated, saving everyone a great deal money on medical expenses - and saving you valuable time. Your records are kept under control more efficiently, creating a far superior level of personal information management than is otherwise possible. With excellent customer support, MedMemory will never leave you in the dark. WHY YOU NEED A PERSONAL HEALTH RECORD!IN AN EMERGENCY:Critical information about your identity, conditions, medications and allergies are available in seconds! ROUTINE PHYSICIAN VISITS: Prevent errors, unnecessary testing, save time and insure accuracy while at a healthcare visit CONTROL YOUR INFORMATION: You have legal control of all your own medical information! Access medical records anytime and lock/unlock data as YOU choose! PEACE OF MIND: Avoid relying on physician’s, hospitals, insurance companies to maintain your medical records ASSIST YOUR PHYSICIANS: Avoid confusion and errors between multiple doctors by having your complete health and medical records available SAVE ON MEDICAL EXPENSES: Decrease your out of pocket health care costs due to redundant expensive medical testing TAX DEDUCTIBLE: MedMemory can be deducted as a health care expense PHYSICIAN DESIGNED/MANAGED:Designed by physicians from the Yale University School of Medicine for their patients. EASY TO USE:Software is extremely very user friendly and intuitive NO computer skills needed - Autolaunches automatically TRUE CLIENT SUPPORT: The best US-based support in the industry! Phone, email, instant messaging and online web-based support available 24-7 .Concierge data loading service available ENDORSED BY PRESIDENT OBAMA: “electronic health records could cut waste, eliminate red tape, and reduce the need to repeat expensive medical tests...it will save billions of dollars and thousands of jobs...it will save lives by reducing the deadly but preventable medical errors that pervade our health care system.” (1/12/2009, CNN.com). Free Medical FormsThe MedMemory PHR program includes 15 free http://medmemory.com/templates.html (A $19.95 Value!) hard to find costly commonly needed medical, health and lifestyle forms (Living Will, Advance Directive & Medical Release) that simplify the development of your Personal Health Record.
Concierge Data Loading ServiceIn addition MedMemory is the only company that offers a low cost flash drive based HIPPA compliant Concierge data loading service to assist you in developing your own Personal Health Record. MedMemory’s only mission is to put only you in control of your medical information! MedMemory is the revolution of the Medical ID the and intelligent choice for the development of your life saving Personal Health Record! Visit our Health Information Manager page to find out more about how MedMemory can help you store, organize, and develop your Personal Health Record. To Receive Free All 15 Medicals Forms On Your MedMemory Medical-Alert Health Information Manager Order Your Drive Today! Pill Box, Key Chain, USB drive. Credit Card USB. Value Model USB To Receive A Free Copy Of Any MedMemory Health Tracking Or Medical Form Email: sales@medmemory.com Or Call 1-888-633-6679
| 
